Search Texas Hunting Guides FREE
Our Sponsors and Partners:
  • GSC Visitor Engagement Path
  • Google Adsense 120x600
Monthly Points Leaders
  1. brownbuck (200)
  2. bonecollector (200)
  3. scott dye (128)
  4. Strike King (127)
  5. ooj32 (125)
  6. Hogboy12 (78)
  7. Buckscore (78)
  8. tx ranger (53)
  9. zalec (51)
  10. CHRIS[LMB]THOM... (47)
Yearly Points Leaders
  1. barnharthunter (2495)
  2. boxroutfitters (1132)
  3. scott dye (1071)
  4. SDOPOC (245)
  5. LSmith6749 (225)
  6. rperezjr (222)
  7. tthorp (220)
  8. hornhunter (216)
  9. brownbuck (200)
  10. hillcountryotf... (200)

Forums >> Texas Hunting >> Texas Bowhunting >> Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Guide Girl
Guide Girl
Guide Girl writes about Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

LIGHTNING

Well, It passed the Senate yesterday (HB 968) with a 31-1 vote. We spoke before the senate committee the week before and it passed with a 4-1 vote and the 1 was someone that came in at the last and replaced another committee member. LSBA lobbied those senators hard too.
 
 Only 3 persons showed on the opposition and one chose not to speak. The two who did speak were the current president of the LSBA, and the past president. Their testimony was based off of non facts or truths so they weren't taken seriously. Comment pertained to crossbows shooting game at 100 yards, which is not the truth. Then the other part of the testimony pertained to the PSE Tac-15 which isn't even on the market. It's a bastard weapon which consists of an AR-15 lower end, and so far, in the Crossbow community here in the USA, there isn't any interest in it. There is some interest in Italy, but would have to get a permit since it has the AR-15 lower end.
 
 The LSBA put out a call to arms at 9AM Friday morning before the Monday 3PM hearing. There were over 2,000 views to the thread, but alot of the membership didn't disagree with allowing crossbows into archery season, so no masses of protestors showed up at the Capitol.
It was Butch and myself, two reps from Barnett Crossbows and one rep from the American Crossbow Federation, then Speaker of the House Gibb showed up to testify FOR.   Also, my good friend Keith Warren and daughter Mattie testified FOR and she did a great job following in brother Colton's footsteps offering testimony  describing what it would mean to her and her hunting girl friends to be able and hunt during Archery season.
 
 I've attach a rough draft of my own testimony.

A Family that Hunts together, stays together. (unless they leave me home!)

Google Adsense 728x90 Leaderboard

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Matt Truitt
Matt Truitt
Matt Truitt writes about
Points: Y (1) / M (0)

So the bill passed, now what has to happen for it to make it into hunting guidelines for the next season?

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Reason

Reason writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

HAPPY

If the governor signs the bill (which he has said he would) the bill becomes law effective September 1, 2009. So, crossbows will be legal this coming archery season in October.

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

elkoholic23

elkoholic23 writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

ELK

I personally do not feel crossbows should be allowed for use during the regualr archery season for anyone except any persons disabled that can not shoot a regular bow.  Pope and Young should be the foundation around "Archery" when it comes to hunting (with archery equipment.)  If Pope and Young do not recognize it as archery equipment, then it shouldn't be allowed.  obviously this is subject to certin cases.  Just like hunting out a vehicle is illegal, unless you can not walk.  In which case you provided the paperwork and get a permit to hunt from your vehicle. 

But this is the beautiful thing about America, you have your thoughts, and I have mine.  I am not here to disagree with you, or put you down.  I am just telling you how I feel.  Wyoming just turned down allowing crossbow use during archery season, with the ammendment of a qualifing disabled person (with proper permit) may hunt during archery season with a crossbow.

Shoot StraightELK

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Matt Truitt
Matt Truitt
Matt Truitt writes about
Points: Y (1) / M (0)

Ill buy a cross bow the day its official.

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

JvT
JvT
JvT writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

My take is that the organizations like LSBA and Pope and Young Club shot themselves in the foot by asking for opposition to the bill by posting the request on the various general hunting online forums. Most of the non bowhunters where not in opposition of the bill. And a good percentage of bowhunters where already in support of the bill. Many who would not have even heard of the bill learned of it this way and used the information given to opposite the bill instead to call for support. Can't remember, but two or three I called responded that the majority of calls were for the bill when I asked. Also in personal conversations with fellow hunters, it is clear to me that these organizations by taking such a strong and public stance have distanced themselves from the general hunting community in Texas as well as some dedicated bowhunters. I was put off by it all somewhat myself. Too many different far reaching reasons given to oppose it and too much sense of elitism. Pushing for an alternative bill such as one with an upper age limit that would be allowed to use crossbows would have been much smarter in my opinion. This is in fact was the original intent of the bill when Homer first considered it due to a friend of his that could not pull a bow due to his age. It was TPWD that changed his mind to allow all hunters, not crossbow manufacturers. These organisations opposing the current bill could have looked more like an advocate to the general hunting community rather than the enemy by asking for the original intent of the bill rather than the one that passed.

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Bowfish
Bowfish
Bowfish writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

Crossbow Tests                                                                                                            March 2005

Great Lakes Crossbow Co.

 

DURANGO

 

The reason for conducting these tests was to establish a basis for performance measurements between modern crossbows and other hunting weapons, most specifically, modern compound bows.  Given the movement to redefine crossbows as conventional archery tackle so as to allow their use during bowhunting-only seasons, it seemed appropriate to provide a means for comparison.  Of particular interest was the accuracy potential of a rested crossbow at extended ranges.  Crossbow manufacturers list velocity and pull weights, but I am not aware of any published accuracy expectations.

 

In early March 2005 I obtained a Great Lakes Crossbow Co.  Durango model crossbow in slightly used condition.  While it does not have as high peak weight (165 pounds) as many of the “high performance” crossbows that peak at 175 pounds to 200 pounds, it does have a 17-inch power stroke, and overall, it’s velocity and kinetic energy ratings compare favorably with other modern crossbows. 

 

This crossbow has an overall weight of 8 ¼ lbs., 34-inch length without the stirrup, and very heavy two-piece limbs with an axle-to-axle length of 27 ¼ inches.  It uses round cams, approximately 2 9/16 inches in diameter.  It comes fitted with a 4 power, parallax adjustable scope with hand adjustable windage and elevation turrets.  The trigger has a pull weight of over 7 pounds, with considerable creep and overtravel.  While the crossbow does have a crossbolt safety, it can’t be engaged until after the crossbow is cocked and it is in an awkward location to operate safely.  Five bolts were also provided.  They were fitted with 100 grain screw-in target points and 5” vanes at a slight straight offset.  The shafts are 2219 Easton aluminum, cut to 22 1/8 inches before inserts and had an average weight, with points, of 476 grains.

 

Although as the shooter, I have no previous experience shooting crossbows, I do have considerable experience in competitive rifle shooting. 

 

 

The first test took place indoors on March 10th.  A total of 4 bolts were shot before the cocking mechanism broke under pressure, causing minor damage and some trepidation on the part of the operator.  The crossbow was rested across a stool with all 4 shots taken at 22 yards.  The initial shot was used to adjust the sights and find a hard spot on the bales where the bolts wouldn’t pass completely through them, and then three shots were taken at the same point of aim.  The first was taken then pulled.  The second entered within ½ inch of the first bolt hole and then a third was shot, which hit right next to the second and almost exactly in the hole that the first was pulled from.  As mentioned, the cocking winch broke at that point, but a three shot group of under ¾ inches was a pretty impressive start.

 

After the winch was repaired I was back at the range on March 12th to shoot at longer distances.  The crossbow was shot from a shooting bench

 

with sandbags.  I had shimmed the back of the scope .050 because I anticipated that the scope would run out of elevation adjustment before it could be held dead-on at the longer ranges I hoped to shoot it at.  It turned out not to be necessary because even at 90 yards, the bolt sailed over the whole bale assembly.  It was recovered but was bent badly due to impact with a tree.  The shims came out.  After four shots at 40 and 60 yards to get “on” the bales I moved to 90 yards and impacted below my aiming point.  I then adjusted the scope to the bulls-eye and shot a four shot group with the four straight bolts I had remaining.  The aiming point was a scrap of white paper.  The first shot hit about 1 inch left of the paper, the second hit it, the third hit about 4 inches right and the final one, less than an inch right.  The final 90-yard group was a horizontal string less than 5 inches across.  Penetration was approximately 8 inches into frozen and practically new excelsior bales.

 

Even though these results surprised me, I felt this crossbow was actually capable of better accuracy.  Conditions were not good with variable winds to at least 10 mph.  Also, I wanted to straighten the bent bolt so I could shoot a 5 shot group.

 

In checking the bolts when I got home, I found that all but one were bent at least .005.  I don’t know if they came that way or it was the result of impact and/or removal from the frozen bales, but I straightened them the best I could.  Unfortunately, the bolt that hit the tree couldn’t be straightened sufficiently.

 

I returned to the range on March 25th.  Conditions were better with light winds, temperature in the low 40’s and clear skies.   With the aid of a laser rangefinder, I set my bench up (across the parking lot) exactly 100 yards from the farthest bale.  I used a rifle bipod instead of sandbags to rest the stock and had adjusted the scope in the rings to avoid canting. 

 

I took two shots to get me close to the bulls-eye, then put up a new target and shot the four almost-straight bolts.  The four shot group measured just slightly less than 4 inches across.  Because I prefer to shoot 5 shot groups for rifle testing, I pulled the bolts, returned to the bench and shot a fifth bolt.  It hit within the holes from the previous four shots, so the 5 shot group at 100 yards measured less than 4 inches across, with 4 of the 5 shots hitting within a 3-inch circle.           

                                                                                             

With straight carbon bolts and perhaps some fine tuning of equipment, I don’t doubt that this could be improved upon, however, this level of long range accuracy exceeded my wildest expectations - and concerns. 

 

I have never fired a crossbow before in my life.  And now within 20 shots can group 5 bolts into 4 inches at 100 yards with a borrowed crossbow.  I can say that I have owned some deer rifles in my life that haven’t grouped that well at 100 yards.  However, because of a much greater trajectory curve for the bolt and longer time of flight, the rifle would still be superior unless wind was light and the exact distance was known.  Which brings up an interesting point.  Ten years ago this very same crossbow wouldn’t have been nearly as effective as a long range weapon because range estimation at that time was far less precise.  However, with the development of technology completely unrelated to crossbows – laser rangefinders - this crossbow in conjunction with one becomes a bona fide 100-yard killing machine.  It would only be a matter of laser ranging the target, dialing the elevation to that exact

 

distance setting on a scope like the one that came with this crossbow, and then putting the crosshairs on the heart and pulling the trigger.  The whole process takes just a few seconds.  Pre-ranging distances and using a mil-dot scope would eliminate even that short time.

 

This is only one crossbow.  I don’t doubt statements by others that have shot crossbows, particularly older models, that say they are not accurate at longer distances.  However, this one is.  And if this and other newer models have this potential, then everyone that can hunt with one has essentially the same potential; because accuracy is almost completely a function of mechanical action with no significant skill required.

 

One consideration that I can’t comment on is potential variations in accuracy using broadheads.  I suspect, but can’t confirm until our sand bunkers thaw out, that given the substantially heavier projectile fired from a crossbow, especially with mechanical broadheads, projectile flight can be controlled.

 

I will leave it to those that read this to form their own opinions on the effect this type of weapon would have on a bow-only season, but there is no question that with widespread use, the effect would be significant, not only on the bow-only season itself, but also upon the harvest dynamics of all seasons for the species involved. 

 

    

Mike Brust,

Wausau, WI

 

        

First 100 yard group      3.9 inch spread

                                                              

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Guide Girl
Guide Girl
Guide Girl writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

While I appreciate this is your first crossbow experience, I feel the need to say that yes, this bow can shoot 100 yards and be within 5 inches, but as well can the vertical compound bow. What is deceiving is, beleiving you can kill an animal at that distance due to lack of energy, but could be done with both the vertical and the crossbow if the kinetic energy was strong enough. Your 165lb bow isn't strong enough. I've guided a buddy from Africa who owns Bow huting Zambia named Strang who showed me the light on that with his 80lb draw compound bow. So far, I havent witnessed a crossbow shooter able to do that but not many play with 200 lb draw bows or higher. Those are really for hunting large game as Cape Buffalo, Asian Buff and Elephant.

With a 165 lb pull bow, for deer, I can tell you from experience, you best keep your shot under 45 yards and hope it's a perfect shot at the heart and not hit a rib bone. I've been testing bows for several years and helped write the book for others detailing what to do or not do. Now, a less dense animal like a bobcat or coyote, I woud shoot at 55 yards. Not deer or anything larger.

I'm not familiar with the bow brand you mention, but once you start shooting broadheads, I would reccomend a 2216 arrow ( not bolt. Bolts have no fletching and are small peices of metal or wood that were shot from the ancient designed bows that were similar to a repeating rifle/shotgun and broke in the middle to cock and load and shot from the hip and not the shoulder). To better the FOC of the arrow, I would play with the 125 gr broadhead, then the 100 gr of the same design to see which performs best from that bow. I beleive the 125gr will be better.

 Using a vertical bow, you have room for human error not utilizing a rest, but other than that, they are very comparable in performance, energy and speed. The best point of this is as we get older, we loose the ability for steady hold/aim, so the crossbow being able to utilize a rest due to the horizontal design, it is great for older archery hunters to continue to hunt archery style, and have confidence in making a clean kill shot. Being able for those hunters as well as ones with disablilties as arthritis or torn rotator cuffs, it allows someone else to be able and cock it, ir use a decive or rope cocker, to continue to hunt as well as women and youth who simply aren't strong enough to draw a vertical where there wouldn't be enough energy for a clean kill.

Good Luck on your learning adventure of a new peice of equipment. And Welcome to a fellow Bow fisherman.

A Family that Hunts together, stays together. (unless they leave me home!)

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Guide Girl
Guide Girl
Guide Girl writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

Quote from JvT " My take is that the organizations like LSBA and Pope and Young Club shot themselves in the foot by asking for opposition to the bill by posting the request on the various general hunting online forums. Most of the non bowhunters where not in opposition of the bill. And a good percentage of bowhunters where already in support of the bill. Many who would not have even heard of the bill learned of it this way and used the information given to opposite the bill instead to call for support. Can't remember, but two or three I called responded that the majority of calls were for the bill when I asked. Also in personal conversations with fellow hunters, it is clear to me that these organizations by taking such a strong and public stance have distanced themselves from the general hunting community in Texas as well as some dedicated bowhunters. I was put off by it all somewhat myself. Too many different far reaching reasons given to oppose it and too much sense of elitism. Pushing for an alternative bill such as one with an upper age limit that would be allowed to use crossbows would have been much smarter in my opinion. This is in fact was the original intent of the bill when Homer first considered it due to a friend of his that could not pull a bow due to his age. It was TPWD that changed his mind to allow all hunters, not crossbow manufacturers. These organisations opposing the current bill could have looked more like an advocate to the general hunting community rather than the enemy by asking for the original intent of the bill rather than the one that passed." Quote.

 I have to say after watching this set of politics around the country and Canada, the LSBA should be commended for keeping their dignity while fighting for something they beleived in. I'm very proud of our fellow Texas hunters for being able to keep face due to the way they fought this battle. We can't say that about some other state Bow Hunting Associations. They even hurt themselves badly and lost face amongst others, and will take several years to repair their dignity and regain their respect they had before hand. Kudos to Texans for this.

 

A Family that Hunts together, stays together. (unless they leave me home!)

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Bowfish
Bowfish
Bowfish writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

TROPHY_HUNTER

GG , This is a post that i found and thought i would post  i have never shoot a crossbow in my life !  my prolem is how many people will grab there new crossbow with a scope that stays cocked they bought the month before and shoot a few times  and head to the woods OCT 1st so they can go bow hunting ? we as bow hunters spend countless Hrs shooting and getting ready with sent control and so forth!  If you have ever hunted public land as i do in north east Texas during rifel season people flood the woods walking around looking for a deer.  I feel now they wil do the same during bow season now thinking the have a wepon that shoots like a gun.

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Guide Girl
Guide Girl
Guide Girl writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)

Bowfish,

Again, it's not a group that does unethical things and we can't assume this is the case due to the weapon of thier choice. It would be the same as discriminating against all vertical shooters becuase their are some that don't/won't practice and hit the woods. We should not be discrininating due to weapon, but as to personal ethics of each and every individual hunter.

 I've hunted public land myself several times, and experienced the hunters on top of hunters eacgh time, and have chosen to look to private property so I have control over that and my own hunting so as not to be disturbed and to allow me to leave eqipment set up as cameras, water, feed, stands, etc.  I just have to deal with wetbacks now.

Public land is just that-public to all.

A Family that Hunts together, stays together. (unless they leave me home!)

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Texas Outdoors
Texas Outdoors
Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about Texas Outdoors writes about
Points: Y (135) / M (1)

My experience shooting a crossbow is that the opportunity for the deer to jump the string starts to happen when taking shots over 25-30 yards. I strongly believe the same rule applies to compound bows. 

 

How much juice is behind the bow or crossbow has little to do with the distance of the shot you should take. For example, whether you are shooting a .243 or a .338, you still have to take into account the distant you are comfortable hitting a 4-6in circle, environmental variables such as wind, the type of animal you are about to shoot, and the consequences of a bad shot. The same applies to archery. Just because my friend can shoot a coke can at 50 yards 4 out of 5 shots with a compound bow doesn't mean he should take that shot on a trophy buck - does that make sense?

 

With my recurve bow I stay inside 15 yards. When using a .12 gauge slug I don't take shots at deer over 50 yards. With a .44 mag not scoped, I don't take shots over 25 yards. With the .308 bolt action and a Leupold VX-7 scope I am staying inside 250 yards, even though I practice shooting clay pidgeons at 400 yards.

 

If it is a hog or coyote I will take any shot at any distance with any legal weapon.

 

All of these methods of harvest have an effective range greater than my comfort and skill level. So what. Learn your weapon. Learn your species. 

 

Some traditional archers think compound bows are as much cheating as many compound hunters think of crossbows. Why not argue about shooting rifles open sight versus using optics? My grandfather hunted with a .30-30 lever action open sight rifle. Does that make him better or worse?

RE: Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Jason Parrish
Jason Parrish
Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about Jason Parrish writes about
Points: Y (0) / M (0)
Travis county

Whether recurve or compound; compound or crossbow; shotgun or pistol or rifle; single shot or repeater; optics or open sight; .243 or .30-06; there will always be those who think they are better than others because of their method of harvest. Meanwhile, there are those who work their every breath and spend their every cent to prevent you from hunting any species with any method - and for this simple reason - I wish we all focused on teaching land stewardship, wildlife management, the discipline of knowing your weapon and knowing your target species and knowing your State Representative and Senator.

Hunt Hard. Fish Smart. Explore Texas.

Forums >> Texas Hunting >> Texas Bowhunting >> Will Crossbows Be Legal During Bow Hunting Season?

Forums Statistics:

  • There are 19781 registered site users.
  • There are currently -6 active users on the site.
  • There are currently 0 registered users that active are on the site (and signed in).
  • There are currently 0 active users in the Forums.

Welcome to the newest registered users: cmitchell rmcgee piloted22 signboy9

Google Adsense 728x90 Leaderboard

Explore Forums Through Common Keywords:

locked lake fishing semihidden public redfish camp blue minnows duck catfish hunts target spinnerbaits hunter points county jigs soft shrimp rifle dove shoot shad turkey first bucks striped fish crankbaits gun hunters crappie trout hunting bold yellow bow hogs call deer lsdexception brush outdoors game lease cut shooting wild channel hog bass hunt texas unhidewhenused shot south rsquo ranch animal wildlife buck priority bait night family ndash free land buy season rigs